06 May 2024

Daily Newsletter

Israel Shuts Down Al Jazeera, Raids Jerusalem Office

The Facts

  • Israeli police shut down the Al Jazeera channel on Sunday over alleged national security concerns. Access to the platform's online content was also restricted.

  • The seized Al Jazeera broadcasting equipment includes cameras, microphones, servers, laptops, and mobile phones.


The Spin

Pro-Israel narrative

Al Jazeera has been glorifying Hamas and supporting anti-Israeli activities, including terrorism and incitement. Shutting it down is, therefore, justified on national security grounds. The network has promoted antisemitism and radical ideologies. It was necessary to pull it off air to counter its dangerous influence and propaganda.

Pro-Palestine narrative

Al Jazeera's shutting down curtails freedom of information, affecting viewers in Israel, Gaza, the West Bank, and global audiences. The network has provided crucial coverage of significant events. The network's Gaza journalists face huge risks under the new labeling as a supposed "threat" to Israeli national security.

Nerd narrative

There's a 50% chance that there will be at least 50K Palestinian civilian deaths in the Israel-Gaza conflict before July 1, 2024, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Panama: Mulino Wins Presidential Vote

The Facts

  • Former Panamanian security minister, José Raúl Mulino, was declared the new president Sunday night after securing 34% of the vote and concessions from his rivals. With 90% of the vote counted, Mulino held a 10-point lead.

  • Mulino entered the race late, replacing former Pres. Ricardo Martinelli after a 10-year jail sentence for money laundering prevented him from running. Mulino faced legal objections to his candidacy in the single-round election.


The Spin

Narrative A

Despite his forced withdrawal from the race due to a jail sentence for corruption, Martinelli's popularity remains high. So an electorate that's used to its politicians having some tainted history backed the Martinelli-endorsed Mulino in hopes he can fix many of Panama's problems.

Narrative B

Mulino benefited from Martinelli's popularity, but whether Mulino can fulfill his promises and fix Panama's troubles remains to be seen considering the deep-rooted corruption that has hindered the country for years. But the people have spoken, so we'll find out soon if Mulino can deliver.

Narrative C

With Mulino in power, Panama and the US will maintain their strategic cooperation, putting an end to the increasing levels of migration via the Darien Gap. Controlling migratory flows in Panama is the first line of defense for resolving the US migration problem. Panama and the US have shared security interests, and Panama will benefit both economically and democratically from this alliance.

See sources

China's Xi in France for First European Trip in 5 Years

The Facts

  • Chinese Pres. Xi Jinping has kicked off his first European tour in five years by meeting with French Pres. Emmanuel Macron and European Commission Pres. Ursula von der Leyen on Monday.

  • During talks, the two European leaders urged China to use its influence on Russia to bring the war in Ukraine to an end. Chinese state media reported that Xi stressed that his country "has been working vigorously" to facilitate peace.


The Spin

Narrative A

Despite the niceties and pomp surrounding the state visit, an enormous trade war is brewing behind the scenes. We can expect Macron to be tough on Xi — tightening the screws on him for China's support to Russia, as well as its damaging trade practices that are hurting the EU economy.

Narrative B

While there are major disagreements between France and China, if anyone is expecting frosty exchanges or a political bust-up, they are mistaken. China is a master of carefully crafted diplomacy and will seek to use this to serve its interests. Meanwhile, Macron can be expected to lay on the charm offensive for the world's second-biggest economy.

Nerd narrative

There's a 58% chance that Xi Jinping will continue leading China in 2030, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Russia Announces Nuclear Drills, Blames 'Provocative' Western Remarks

The Facts

  • Russia on Monday said it would soon hold military exercises that included practice for the preparation and deployment of tactical nuclear weapons, blaming "provocative statements and threats of certain Western officials."

  • Though Russia's nuclear forces regularly hold exercises with such weapons — which are intended for battlefield use and are not as powerful as conventional nuclear warheads — it was the first time that Russia publicly announced plans to hold such drills.


The Spin

Pro-establishment narrative

Russia is once again threatening the West with nuclear weapons. Putin did a similar thing when Britain said it would provide Ukraine with armor-piercing shells containing depleted uranium. This is the Kremlin's playbook for seeking to scare its enemies into obsequience.

Pro-Russia narrative

Despite Russia's warnings, the West continues to escalate the conflict by suggesting that NATO troops will be stationed in Ukraine, and by allowing it to strike in Russian territory — hundreds of miles from where the conflict is taking place. Russia had no choice but to respond to these Western provocations.

Nerd narrative

There is a 12% chance that there will be a global thermonuclear war by 2070, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Scotland: Swinney Elected SNP Leader, Set to Become First Minister

The Facts

  • John Swinney was elected without opposition as the Scottish National Party's (SNP) new leader Monday. The news comes a week after First Minister Humza Yousaf announced his resignation.

  • Swinney won the position following activist Graeme McCormick's decision to pull out of the race Sunday, and former finance secretary Kate Forbes's announcement last week that she would not run after being offered a "significant" role in a new government by Swinney.


The Spin

Left narrative

Swinney, who has participated in Scottish politics for decades, knows how to play the game well. Instead of bashing anti-independence members of the Scottish parliament, Swinney has set out a cross-party agenda aimed at rejuvenating key sectors, including healthcare and schooling. Scotland has recently endured unnecessary political turmoil, and now it's time for Swinney to bring back normality.

Right narrative

Swinney's entire career is connected to Nicola Sturgeon's tainted legacy and also support for many unpopular gender and hate-speech policies that have led to the downfall of his party. The appointment of Swinney shows that the SNP hasn't learned from its mistakes and is incapable of providing the cure to Scotland's problems.

Nerd narrative

There's a 5% chance that Scotland leaves the UK by Jan. 1, 2030, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Columbia Cancels Campus-Wide Commencement

The Facts

  • Columbia University has announced that it will cancel its university-wide commencement ceremony scheduled for May 15 due to the ongoing pro-Palestinian protests.

  • The university will instead hold various smaller-scale celebrations for the institution's individual schools. Many of the smaller celebrations will take place at the university's Baker Athletics Complex, far from the protests taking place on the main campus.


The Spin

Pro-establishment narrative

It would be logistically difficult to organize a large-scale event like a campus-wide commencement ceremony amidst the protests happening at Columbia University — especially since some of these protests have turned violent. Smaller-scale individual ceremonies that will take place off the main campus are a fair trade-off that will still allow students to be celebrated for their accomplishments while also accommodating security concerns.

Conservative narrative

A small minority of students have ruined it for everyone else. It's a shame that Columbia has canceled its campus-wide commencement ceremony. Many of these students have been looking forward to this day for years, especially since the majority of them were unable to have in-person graduation ceremonies during high school because of the COVID pandemic. Colleges must regain order on their campuses and not allow this anarchy to continue any longer.

Progressive narrative

The student protests are on the right side of history. This is a social movement pushing back against the atrocities in Gaza, urging divestment from companies enabling Israel's ruthless operations against Palestine, and the resulting crackdown by militarized police. This is not just a US issue anymore — this is now becoming an international movement of solidarity.

Nerd narrative

There's a 5% chance that an independent review will find UNRWA staff involvement in the October 7, 2023 Hamas attacks, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Qantas to Pay $79M to Settle 'Ghost Flights' Lawsuit

The Facts

  • Australia's Qantas Airways on Monday agreed to pay a 100M Australian dollar ($66M) penalty and AU$20M ($13M) in compensation to passengers to settle a lawsuit accusing it of selling thousands of tickets on long-canceled flights.

  • According to the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission, Qantas misled and deceived its customers by advertising seats on more than 8K "ghost flights" between May 2021 and July 2022.


The Spin

Narrative A

Qantas should've faced much stiffer penalties for lying to flyers, blaming COVID for its no-show, and dodging responsibility for its overloaded systems. If there's a silver lining here, it's the message this penalty — while not tough enough — will send to airlines worldwide about treating travelers well and the consequences of their actions if they don't.

Narrative B

Though its services were hampered by COVID, Qantas admitted its failure to promptly provide cancellation notifications and maintain its high standards. So Qantas is compensating wronged customers in addition to revamping its processes and improving its technology. This settlement restores Qantas’ status as a marquee carrier.

Nerd narrative

There's a 50% chance that the next commercial supersonic flight occur by November, 2030, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Trump Fined Again for Violating Gag Order

The Facts

  • Former Pres. Donald Trump, the presumptive Republican nominee for the 2024 presidential election, was fined the maximum of $1K again Monday for violating the gag order imposed in his New York hush money trial.

  • Previously, Judge Juan Merchan last week fined Trump $1K each for nine Truth Social posts that were deemed in violation of the gag order, which prohibits Trump from making public statements related to likely witnesses, prosecutors, court staff, or their families.


The Spin

Anti-Trump narrative

This is a small penalty for Trump's blatant flaunting of the gag order. Merchan may have to up the ante, and even consider jail time if Trump doesn't cease attempting to put his thumb on the scale of justice with insulting posts and accusatory statements about witnesses and other members of the court.

Pro-Trump narrative

It's absurd that Trump is being punished when people like Daniels and Cohen have been profiting off public interviews and their accusations about the former president. Trump has merely been reiterating his long-held, correct views about this case being a witch hunt against him, and his First Amendment rights have been taken away.

Nerd narrative

There's a 12% chance that Trump will testify at the hush money trial, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Report: US Shared COVID Lab Leak Evidence With UK in Late 2020

The Facts

  • The Telegraph has reported that the US in late 2020 shared significant evidence with the UK suggesting the COVID pandemic likely originated from a lab leak in China, but leaders from the “Five Eyes” intelligence alliance allegedly ignored the reports.

  • From October to December 2020, then-US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo reportedly shared information collected at the start of the pandemic that "pointed to the high likelihood that this was indeed a lab leak."


The Spin

Establishment-critical narrative

As time passes, it's becoming apparent that the lab-leak theory had more legs than the greater world knew during the first year of the pandemic. Sadly, the theory was ignored over time because officials in other countries didn't want to be associated with Trump. Vital evidence may have been lost while prominent governments were turning a blind eye.

Pro-establishment narrative

Governments haven't ruled out the lab leak theory, they're just being cautious about touting it while the scientific community continues to work on this difficult puzzle. It would be irresponsible to do otherwise.

Nerd narrative

There is a 9% chance that at least two public health agencies will claim that COVID-19 more likely than not originated in a laboratory before Jan. 1, 2025, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Hamas Accepts Cease-Fire Deal, Rafah Operation to Continue

The Facts

  • After Israel called for the evacuation of eastern Rafah on Monday, Hamas announced it would accept a cease-fire deal. However, the details were unclear and the situation continues progressing rapidly.

  • Israel's war cabinet, after reviewing Hamas' answer, voted unanimously to push ahead with an operation in Rafah "to apply military pressure on Hamas." Israel said Hamas' response was "far from Israel’s obligatory demands." Nonetheless, Israeli negotiators are set to talk with regional mediators for further cease-fire discussions.


The Spin

Pro-establishment narrative

It's taken a lot of work by representatives of several different countries to hammer out a deal that's the best outcome for both the hostages and the Palestinian people. Hamas has agreed to this three-part deal, and it would behoove Netanyahu to also accept it without a major attack on Rafah.

Pro-Israel narrative

Israel must move ahead cautiously because so much about this deal is still unclear. Hamas has used deceptive tactics in the past to stall and gain time to prevent Israeli military actions, and it seems Hamas is attempting to insert last-minute clauses in an attempt to pressure Israel to accept a bad deal.

Pro-Palestine narrative

The most consistent obstacle in these negotiations continues to be Netanyahu and his far-right government. If he wasn't pursuing salvaging his political career — and if the Biden administration wasn't so weak geopolitically — perhaps thousands of lives could have been saved. Either way, it's now up to Israel to ensure the end of this brutal war.

Nerd narrative

There's a 5% chance that a shared power arrangement will have de facto power in the Gaza Strip on Jan. 1, 2025, according to the Metaculus prediction community.

See sources

Sign up to our daily newsletter