© 2026 Improve the News Foundation.
All rights reserved.
Version 8.2.1
A university that cannot let a controversial speaker be heard is not teaching anyone to think. Condemning a view is free speech, but blockading the gates so others cannot hear it is not. Banning a man makes him a martyr and spares his critics from ever refuting him. Controversial views should be challenged, not suppressed, and treating students as adults means trusting them to hear a lecture and judge it.
Academic freedom does not oblige a university to lend its good name to every claim. Arguments that Black people are less able belong to a long history of racial hierarchy, and hosting them at Oxford lends them authority that falls hardest on Black students forced to prove their place. Speech is met with evidence, and it is against him. Free speech sits alongside equality law, not above it.