United States of America

Surveillance Video Shown in Charlie Kirk Murder Hearing

Is the evidence against Tyler Robinson now overwhelming or is the prosecution's case so far built on guesswork?

Published JUL 8

Surveillance Video Shown in Charlie Kirk Murder Hearing

Story

Above: Defense attorney Kathryn Nester looks at Tyler Robinson during a preliminary hearing in Provo, Utah, on July 7. Image credit: Trent Nelson-Pool/Getty Images

The Facts

A Utah preliminary hearing entered its second day on Tuesday, as prosecutors presented surveillance footage they say shows Tyler Robinson, 23, moving through Utah Valley University's campus on Sept. 10, 2025 — the day conservative activist Charlie Kirk was fatally shot there.
The Salt Lake Tribune
Reuters
FOX 10 Phoenix on Youtube
State investigator David Hull testified that footage showed a man prosecutors identified as Robinson arriving on campus around 8:30 a.m. local time, eating at a Chick-fil-A and making contact with Turning Point USA staff before leaving and returning multiple times.
The Salt Lake Tribune
New York Post
Hull testified that Robinson returned to campus in different clothing and walking with a noticeable limp, which prosecutors said was consistent with a rifle concealed in his pants, before footage allegedly showed him climbing to the roof of the Losee Center.
The Gateway Pundit
Kuer
FBI DNA testing found Robinson's DNA and that of his roommate and former romantic partner, Lance Twiggs, on a screwdriver recovered from the roof, a towel and a bolt-action rifle found in a wooded area near campus. The defense questioned the reliability of the DNA analysis.
Utah News Dispatch
FOX News
BBC News
Defense attorney Kathy Nester challenged key evidence, noting no shell casings were found on the rooftop and that some witnesses described a different suspect. She also argued the surveillance videos could prejudice potential jurors if shown publicly.
BBC News
The Salt Lake Tribune
Prosecutors sought to admit a statement from Kirk associate David Engelhardt arguing Kirk's political and religious views were intertwined, citing a "victim targeting enhancement." Judge Tony Graf provisionally admitted the statement but did not publish it in the courtroom. The preliminary hearing on whether the case proceeds to trial concludes Friday.
FOX News
Kuer
Utah News Dispatch

Sources Split

LEFT

CENTER

RIGHT

ESTAB
CRIT

CENTER

PRO
ESTAB

The Spin

Narrative A

The evidence against Tyler Robinson is overwhelming — text messages, witness testimony and now surveillance footage all point to one shooter. Conspiracy theories about fake deaths, exploding microphones and Israeli plots have zero evidentiary basis, and even Robinson's own defense team hasn't argued someone else pulled the trigger. When the rubber meets the road in a courtroom, speculation without proof isn't a defense.

Megyn Kelly on Youtube

The New York Times

Narrative B

No footage of the actual shot exists — the state's own witness confirmed it in open court. The figure on the surveillance footage appears far taller than Robinson's documented height, and Robinson's car was allegedly spotted being driven by a completely different person after the shooting. Assuming a man fired a rifle from a rooftop, with zero video of the act, is a foundation of guesswork.

Danks on X