© 2026 Improve the News Foundation.
All rights reserved.
Version 8.2.1
A case built on an expert's say-so falls apart when that expert was barred from treating children over insulin concerns and the jury never heard a word. Hindmarsh was sold to the jury as the pre-eminent insulin expert even as UCLH warned the GMC about the risk posed to children. Sally Clark's wrongful conviction in 1999 shows exactly where undisclosed medical evidence leads — a lesson that resonates directly with Letby's case.
The insulin opinion was one strand of a circumstantial case that included Letby's presence at every collapse, 200-plus hidden handover sheets and a note reading "I am evil, I did this." Letby accepted at trial that both babies were poisoned; the dispute was only over who did it. A tribunal declined to suspend Hindmarsh, and the Court of Appeal found none of the appeal grounds arguable.