Hong Kong Court Upholds Convictions of 12 'HK47' Activists

Does Hong Kong's ruling prove judicial independence or expose political persecution of democratic opposition?

Published 2 hours ago

Hong Kong Court Upholds Convictions of 12 'HK47' Activists

story

Above: A supporter holds a poster showing some of the 47 pro-democracy activists in Hong Kong on July 8, 2021. Image credit: Anthony Wallace/AFP/Getty Images

The Spin

Pro-China narrative

The court's decision to uphold convictions and also dismiss the prosecution's appeal against an acquittal proves Hong Kong's judiciary operates with true independence and fairness. This meticulous ruling severely punishes genuine threats to national security while firmly protecting defendants' legal rights, demonstrating that the rule of law shines brighter than ever under "one country, two systems."

Global Times

Anti-China narrative

The court's rejection of these appeals exposes the politically motivated persecution of peaceful opposition in Hong Kong, where organizing democratic primaries now results in lengthy prison sentences. These defendants committed no internationally recognized crime but face punishment simply for exercising fundamental rights to free expression and political participation.

Amnesty International

HK Labour Rights Monitor on X