After a month of searching, man learns from NBC News that DHS sent his brother to El Salvador
NBCAPR 26
Venezuelan Migrant Files $1.3M Claim Against US Over Deportation
Above: Detained Venezuelans board a flight to Venezuela on July 18, 2025, in La Paz, El Salvador. Image copyright: El Salvador Presidency/Handout/Getty Images
The Spin
Republican narrative
The Trump administration acted decisively to protect Americans from dangerous gang members who pose a genuine security threat. Rengel was identified as a Tren de Aragua associate based on his tattoos and other indicators, and his removal was necessary to prevent further criminal activity. The administration won't allow foreign terrorist enemies to operate freely and endanger American citizens.
Establishment-critical narrative
This case represents a clear violation of due process rights where an innocent man was wrongfully detained based on flimsy evidence. Rengel had legal status, was scheduled for an immigration hearing in 2028, and was deported without proper procedures to a notorious prison where he suffered systematic abuse. Rengel’s case underscores the consequences of bypassing due process in favor of hardline immigration tactics.
Metaculus Prediction
Editor's Note
This story currently has limited reporting from right-wing sources. We will continue to monitor all major outlets and update our coverage as additional perspectives become available