Flight carrying 242 people bound for London has crashed in Ahmedabad, India
NPR Online NewsMAY 30
Air India Flight to London Crashes in Ahmedabad, Over 200 Killed, One Lone Survivor
Above: Responders at the crash site of Air India Ltd. flight AI171 in Ahmedabad, Gujarat, India, on June 12, 2025. Image copyright: Siddharaj Solanki/Bloomberg via Getty Images
The Spin
Narrative A
This tragic accident highlights serious concerns about aviation safety protocols and aircraft maintenance standards, as well as raises questions about the aircraft's design and Boeing's quality control — especially given the company's recent history with the 737 Max incidents. The fact that experienced pilots issued a Mayday call within seconds suggests a potential mechanical failure that demands a thorough investigation.
Narrative B
While this horrific tragedy represents an unprecedented failure for the 787 Dreamliner model, commercial flying remains statistically the safest form of travel. The Boeing 787 has completed millions of flights since its introduction in 2011, carrying over one billion passengers safely. Initial investigations must focus on specific circumstances rather than broader aircraft design issues, as isolated incidents don't necessarily indicate systemic problems in the aviation sector.