UK: Palace Disputes Claims of Diana's Brother in New Book

Is Earl Spencer an unreliable narrator settling old scores or the last truthful guardian of Diana's memory?
UK: Palace Disputes Claims of Diana's Brother in New Book
Above: Then-Prince Charles And Princess Diana During A Royal Tour In Toronto, Canada, in October 1991. Image credit: Tim Graham Photo Library/Getty Images

The Spin


Pro-establishment narrative

Earl Spencer is no reliable narrator of Diana's life. The same man who wrote to her in 1996 branding her a manipulative liar and refusing her sanctuary at Althorp, with his own long list of troubled marriages and relationships, is now seeking his time in the spotlight. The palace's dignified response reaffirms the difference in class between the two parties.

Establishment-critical narrative

The palace's unconventional denial is a clear signal that the allegations have reminded Charles of the appalling manner in which Diana was treated. Coldness and cruelty defined that marriage while she was alive, so expecting warmth after her death is fantasy. Her brother has spent decades protecting Diana's memory and frantic smears will not succeed in suppressing the truth.


Metaculus Prediction

© 2026 Improve the News Foundation. All rights reserved.Version 7.16.0

© 2026 Improve the News Foundation.

All rights reserved.

Version 7.16.0