© 2026 Improve the News Foundation.
All rights reserved.
Version 8.2.1
No backdoor lets only the good guys in, and a government that demands one in secret asks for trust it has not earned. The tribunal rightly called the national security case for silence fanciful, as officials briefed the press while refusing to confirm the order. Encryption gives people control over their own information, so any power to break it needs public debate and limits, not secret notices.
Privacy matters, but it cannot become an absolute right that ignores public safety, and the two are not mutually exclusive. Encryption that leaves companies unable to answer a warrant, or to see abuse on their own services, lets offenders avoid detection while child abuse carries on. When a court authorizes access, providers should be able to give it, and protections should come before rollout.