© 2026 Improve the News Foundation.
All rights reserved.
Version 8.0.0
Treating New Yorkers who march for Gaza or Black lives like terror suspects was always a constitutional insult, and ending that with Commissioner Tisch's backing is long overdue. A civilian-led dialogue division plus 30 trained de-escalation officers, with kettling, tear gas and long guns banned, protects speech at no extra cost and no lost jobs. Chi Ossé's CURB Act reforms finally put dialogue ahead of batons and bikes.
Swapping the city's best-trained rapid-response unit for a civilian-led protest division trades real safety for optics. The SRG responded to just 6% of protests in 2025, deploying only when criminal activity emerged, yet its disbandment risks pulling detectives from victims' cases to cover hundreds of demonstrations. After IEDs nearly detonated near Gracie Mansion recently, every minute of delayed response is a gamble. This is policing shaped by political loyalties.