Lindsay Clancy Back in Court Amid Retrial Questions

Was this a psychiatric emergency or is there something more?
Lindsay Clancy Back in Court Amid Retrial Questions
Above: Lindsay Clancy attends a status hearing in Plymouth, Massachusetts on Sept. 2. Image credit: Greg Derr/AFP/Getty Images

The Facts

  • Lindsay Clancy appeared in Plymouth Superior Court on Tuesday for the first time since a mistrial was declared Sept. 4 in her murder trial over the strangling deaths of her three children at their Duxbury, Massachusetts, home in 2023.
  • Defense lawyer Kevin Reddington argued there was a "total and complete lack of evidence" that Clancy killed the children, telling Judge William Sullivan the case rests on speculation. Prosecutor Shanan Buckingham called the claim "laughable."
  • Buckingham said the record was voluminous, citing Clancy being alone with the children, cellphone data and surveillance footage backing her husband's account of being sent on errands, and her DNA on the exercise bands used in the strangulations.

Sources Split


The Spin


Narrative A

Postpartum psychosis is a real psychiatric emergency, and Massachusetts rightly puts the burden on prosecutors to prove sanity beyond a reasonable doubt. A jury split overwhelmingly toward mercy shows the case for accountability was never there.

Narrative B

The prosecution has leverage in this case. The evidence is mounting against Lindsey Clancy, and it's likely that justice will run its due course.


Go Deeper

The Lindsay Clancy Case
The Lindsay Clancy Case
© 2026 Improve the News Foundation. All rights reserved.Version 8.0.0

© 2026 Improve the News Foundation.

All rights reserved.

Version 8.0.0