Crime & justice

Duterte's War on Drugs

Is Duterte a victim of politically motivated charges or a historic symbol of accountability for crimes against humanity?

Published 2 hours ago

Context

Above: Former Philippine president Rodrigo Duterte takes an oath as he attends a Senate probe on the drug war during his administration, in Manila on Oct. 28, 2024. Image credit: Jam Sta Rosa/AFP/Getty Images

The Spin

Left narrative

The ICC's confirmation of all crimes against humanity charges against Rodrigo Duterte marks a historic rupture in elite impunity. Thousands were killed systematically under a state-sanctioned war on drugs, and a domestic justice system consistently failed victims. Duterte became the first Asian former head of state delivered to the ICC, signaling that even heads of state must answer for widespread, systematic murder. For families who carried grief in silence for years, this confirmation affirms their voices have been heard and accountability is no longer beyond reach.

Amnesty International Australia Jacobin Icc-Cpi

Right narrative

No direct order to kill was ever issued — not one witness among the 49 charged incidents can testify that Rodrigo Duterte commanded anyone to commit murder. The prosecution relies on self-confessed killers granted virtual immunity, whose contradictory statements amount to assumption layered upon hearsay. Speeches were cherry-picked while dozens of instances stressing lawful conduct were ignored. Evidence is wholly insufficient, charges are politically motivated and the defense demands adequate time to ensure a fair trial.