Trump DOJ Sues NYC, Mayor Adams Over Sanctuary Policies

Trump DOJ Sues NYC, Mayor Adams Over Sanctuary Policies
Above: Eric Adams, mayor of New York, before an interview July 17, 2025. Image copyright: Victor J. Blue/Bloomberg/Getty Images

The Spin

Republican narrative

If New York won't protect its citizens, it's up to the federal government to do so and to hold New York's failed officials accountable. The data shows that failing to cooperate with ICE makes New York and other cities far more dangerous. The recent shooting of a CBP officer shows how urgent it is to roll back sanctuary policies.

Democratic narrative

Evidence shows that sanctuary laws make communities safer by encouraging immigrant cooperation with police and preventing unconstitutional detention. It's the Trump administration's use of violent, masked ICE agents who target immigrants at courthouses and schools that's creating fear and undermining public safety.

Metaculus Prediction



The Controversies



Political split

LEFT

RIGHT

More neutral political stance articles