MLB was wrong to reinstate Pete Rose: Why nothing has changed about hits leader's baseball gambling
CBS1 day
MLB Lifts Pete Rose's Ban, Opening Hall of Fame Path
Above: Former Philadelphia Phillies player Pete Rose acknowledges the crowd before the game against the Washington Nationals at Citizens Bank Park on Aug. 7, 2022, in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Image copyright: Mitchell Leff/Stringer/Getty Images Sport via Getty Images
The Spin
Narrative A
The reinstatement rightfully acknowledges that deceased individuals can no longer threaten baseball's integrity, while the lifetime ban served its deterrent purpose. Rose’s unmatched achievements — including the all-time hits record — deserve a place in Cooperstown. With the case now heading to the Classic Committee, his legacy can finally be judged on merit, as it was always meant to be.
Narrative B
This decision undermines baseball's fundamental integrity and sets a dangerous precedent that could encourage future gambling violations. Rose repeatedly lied about his actions for 15 years, never showed genuine remorse, and continued gambling even after his ban. His reinstatement, even posthumously, sends the wrong message about the consequences of violating baseball's most sacred rule.
Narrative C
It’s a shame MLB waited until Pete Rose was gone to do what should’ve been done years ago. The lifetime ban achieved its purpose — but so did Rose, with more hits and games played than anyone in history. Now, he’ll never know the honor of Hall of Fame induction. Justice this delayed isn’t justice at all. Cooperstown may open its doors, but it’s far too late for Charlie Hustle to walk through them.