Trump's tariffs poised for major test before federal appeals court today
CBSAUG 1
Federal Appeals Court Questions Trump's Emergency Tariff Powers
Above: Vehicles at the Canada-US border in St-Bernard-de-Lacolle, Quebec, Canada, on March 6, 2025. Image copyright: Graham Hughes/Bloomberg/Getty Images
The Spin
Pro-Trump narrative
Trump's tariffs are essential tools for protecting American national security and economic interests against decades of unfair trade practices. The president rightfully used emergency powers to address genuine crises including the fentanyl epidemic killing thousands of Americans and massive trade deficits that have decimated manufacturing communities. These tariffs are already generating record revenue and forcing other nations to negotiate fairer deals.
Anti-Trump narrative
The tariffs constitute dangerous presidential overreach that violate constitutional separation of powers by bypassing Congress's authority to impose taxes. IEEPA never mentions tariffs and was intended for genuine emergencies, not to address trade deficits that have existed for five decades. This unlimited authority claim threatens to undermine democratic governance and impose regressive taxes on American consumers.