South Africa Urgently Appeals to ICJ on Gaza Famine
Consortium NewsMAR 2024
WCK Accuses Israel of 'Systematically' Killing Gaza Staff
Image copyright: Hugh Hastings/Stringer/Getty Images News via Getty Images
The Spin
Anti-Israel narrative
The deadly Israeli strike on World Central Kitchen staff has led to the suspension of operations by the NGO and other humanitarian groups in Gaza despite widespread starvation and other desperate conditions. This ought to renew calls for accountability from Israel as well as insistence on a thorough investigation into the incident, as it shows Israel continues to defy norms and violate cardinal international treaties.
Pro-Israel narrative
Israel has acknowledged responsibility for Monday's accidental airstrike, but the real blame for this tragedy must be placed on Hamas for instigating the conflict. The IDF has maintained efforts to minimize civilian deaths despite Hamas operating in densely populated areas to exploit confusion and provoke lethal errors.
Narrative C
The number of attacks on aid workers has risen globally since the late 1990s, as conflict has shifted to urban areas, posing increasing risks to civilians and aid workers. Local activists in these regions face the highest risks but receive less attention than foreign volunteers. Gaza's conflict has complicated aid work, raising questions about future humanitarian efforts.