Crime

Jury Determines Trump Should Pay $83.3M in Carroll Defamation Case

JAN 26 2024·Updated JAN 30 2024

Story

Image credit: Alexi J. Rosenfeld/Stringer/Getty Images News via Getty Images

The Facts

A federal grand jury determined Friday that former Pres. Donald Trump should pay $83.3M to E. Jean Carroll for defamatory statements made in 2019. This total is over eight times what Carroll had asked for and includes $18.3M in compensatory damages and $65M in punitive damages.
CNN
Last year, Trump was found to have sexually assaulted Carroll in the 1990s before defaming her by his public denial of the event.
wsj.com
Taking the witness stand, Trump confirmed that he had heard his deposition played in court, said he stood by his previous statements, and denied he ever threatened Carroll in his social media posts. Trump's attempts to answer beyond the yes/no limit imposed on him by the court were removed from the record by Judge Lewis A. Kaplan.
FOX News
The judge removed Trump's claim that Carroll had "said something that [he] considered a false accusation" and that he had "just wanted to defend myself, my family and frankly, the presidency."
BBC News
Kaplan imposed the restrictions because the only purpose of this trial is to determine how much Trump must pay Carroll in damages.
BBC News
Carroll, who was awarded $5M by a jury in a related case in May, was seeking an additional $10M for Trump's repeated denials of her accusations. The former president has publicly denied the sexual assault on social media, during a CNN interview, in news conferences, and during his presidential campaign.
The New York Times

Sources Split

LEFT

CENTER

RIGHT

ESTAB
CRIT

CENTER

PRO
ESTAB

The Spin

Anti-Trump narrative

Trump's arrogance and unapologetic behavior led to him having to pay far more in damages than what Carroll was seeking. In other cases currently being adjudicated, Trump has claimed he's worth more than the prosecutor's claim, so it's no surprise Carroll saw a much larger sum in the end.

The New Republic

Pro-Trump narrative

Kaplan's courtroom rules were not worthy of Trump's respect, considering the baseless accusations the judge has allowed Carroll to throw Trump's way. Like many people before during Trump's time as a prominent public figure, Carroll and Kaplan are trying to destroy Trump for political reasons.