Police: Six-Year-Old Shoots Teacher At Virginia School

Image copyright: AP [via The New York Times]

The Spin

Democratic narrative

Friday's shooting is a lesson in gun violence and must renew calls for more significant gun restrictions in the US. This isn't a local issue but rather a larger problem that requires political courage at the federal level. School shootings will not stop until elected leaders take meaningful action and stand up to the gun lobbyists.

Republican narrative

While stricter gun laws haven't been proven to prevent shootings like this, such laws have been shown to strip law-abiding gun owners of their constitutionally-protected rights. The gun violence epidemic in the US is a symptom of a broader mental health crisis, so there should be a concerted effort to address the core sociological problems that lead to acts like these.

Narrative C

There's no tangible link between mental health and gun violence. School shootings represent a small percentage of all gun violence, and mental illness is not a factor in most. Blaming mental health issues prevents the government from finding real solutions and stigmatizes those with mental health disorders.

Metaculus Prediction


Political split

LEFT

RIGHT

More neutral political stance articles

Sign Up for Our Free Newsletters
Sign Up for Our Free Newsletters

Sign Up!
Sign Up Now!