Controversy
Josh Hammer
CBS News
Metaculus
Lines
Tuoliutuoxiaoji
Mollie Hemingway
PredMart
+2
Status:Open

Will a U.S. Supreme Court Seat Become Vacant in 2026?

Will a U.S. Supreme Court Seat Become Vacant in 2026?

Claims

Mollie Hemingway
Mollie Hemingway"I don’t have inside information, but I would not put it outside the realm of possibility that there might be a retirement at the end of this term.”Apr 20, 2026
PredMart
PredMart"Samuel Alito retirement odds at 14.5% for 2026, 42.5% by mid-2027."Aug 04, 2026
"Polymarket, a platform where users wager on political outcomes, has placed the probability of Alito retiring before the end of 2026 at roughly 54 percent."Jul 20, 2026
Tuoliutuoxiaoji
Tuoliutuoxiaoji"Prediction markets and legal scholars are closely watching key indicators: the probability of Justice Thomas retiring (currently 35% by end of 2026)."Jul 05, 2026
ABC News
ABC News"Alito, 76, has been hiring clerks for next term and intends to continue serving into at least 2027."Apr 18, 2026
Federal News Network
Federal News Network"If the Democrats control the Senate, it is a question as to whether a SCOTUS vacancy will be filled during Trump’s final two years. "Apr 20, 2026
Kalshi
Kalshi"There is a 1.8% chance that Samuel Alito will retire before September 1, 2026."Aug 03, 2026
Werner Zagrebbi
Werner Zagrebbi"The market is implicitly pricing ~18% chance of a 2026 vacancy created by someone other than Alito."Jul 10, 2026
Lines
Lines“NO price: $0.63, implying a 62.5% probability the court remains unchanged through year end.”Aug 04, 2026
CBS News
CBS News"That indicates that this year, with the midterm elections on the horizon, President Trump will not be able to plan on an opportunity to make his fourth nomination to the Supreme Court."Apr 18, 2026
Josh Hammer
Josh Hammer"I am simply saying that if you are being as risk-averse and cautious as possible, that this is as good a time as any for one of, potentially both of them, to step down."Aug 03, 2026
"Alito would retire in 2025, and Thomas in 2026."Jul 21, 2025
Damon Root
Damon Root"The idea of Alito (or Thomas) retiring this year is conceivable."Feb 18, 2026
John Yoo
John Yoo"I would be utterly shocked and speechless if Justice Thomas were to retire this year."Aug 03, 2026
John Yoo
John Yoo"The window for Trump to nominate a Supreme Court justice - or any federal judge - with a friendly Republican Senate could be closing by the end of this year."Aug 03, 2026
Manifold
Manifold"There is a 68% chance that Samuel Alito will be the next Supreme Court justice to retire/die."Jul 01, 2026
© 2026 Improve the News Foundation. All rights reserved.Version 7.7.3

© 2026 Improve the News Foundation.

All rights reserved.

Version 7.7.3