2025 Baseball Hall of Fame voting results: Ichiro Suzuki elected alongside CC Sabathia, Billy Wagner
CBSJAN 19
Ichiro Suzuki Leads Historic 2025 Baseball Hall of Fame Class
Above: Former Seattle Mariners player Ichiro Suzuki reacts as he is elected into the National Baseball Hall of Fame, after receiving the results on Jan. 21, 2025, at T-Mobile Park in Seattle, Washington. Image copyright: Steph Chambers/Staff/Getty Images Sport via Getty Images
The Spin
Narrative A
This year’s Hall of Fame class perfectly embodies the diversity and greatness of the sport. Ichiro Suzuki, the first Asian player elected, dazzled with 3K hits and unmatched consistency. CC Sabathia, a 6'6", 300-pound force, ranks with legends like Carlton and Johnson. Billy Wagner overcame adversity to become the toughest pitcher to hit. Their unique paths highlight baseball's inclusivity and rich history.
Narrative B
The Hall of Fame has overlooked several deserving players, especially those linked to steroids like A-Rod and Bonds. The steroid era was widespread, with many in baseball benefiting, suggesting a level playing field. Excluding these players ignores their undeniable talent and contributions to the game, perpetuating an era of hypocrisy in baseball's hallowed halls.